This poll was on CNN a while ago. I don’t remember the article associated with it.
Interesting results. I discussed a similar CNN poll here last June.
My answers are “Yes, but within limits”, and somewhere in between #1 and #2 for the second question. I welcome some limits, such as limits on the rate that entities are allowed to reproduce. For more on why this is necessary, see The Future of Human Evolution by philosopher Nick Bostrom.
When significant transhumanist technologies become available and start percolating throughout the population, some may opt to live in human-only societies. Should certain segments of humanity be allowed to ban all augmented persons and enhancement prosthetics from their countries?
I think the questions are a bit misleading, basically because they say “right”.
I think its more appropriate to ask “Do I think that humans should be limited when its coming to enhance them selfs ?”
The right is the privilege of the strong. Do we have the right to eat millions of cows ?
Yes, because we can.
Do I subjectively think its ethical ? No.
I doubt that there will be any worldwide legislation on this (although I could turn out to be wrong). What I think will happen is that different regions will have different policies and the humans will eventually diverge into multiple new species – some biological, some non-biological, and some both. The seemingly inevitable march towards speciation will cause all kind of trouble. Perhaps this will be manageable. We can look to existing ecosystems for a guide to how multiple large mammals can coexist peacefully, but bearing in mind human nature as it has manifested itself in recent history the future could turn out to be punctuated by grim genocidal struggles for dominance.
The results of the poll are suspect, but at least the questions are being asked in a public venue. That’s a good thing.
Your last question was a nice one, Michael!
“Should certain segments of humanity be allowed to ban all augmented persons and enhancement prosthetics from their countries?”
The interesting ‘hook’ to that question is that human beings are already being enhanced. Corrective surgeries, medical implants of several kinds and types, eyeglasses, hearing aids, prosthetics, pharmaceuticals, the list goes on. So the question could easily apply to those of us who have already been “enhanced,” as well. (Eyeglasses and knee surgery, in my case.)
If we answer the question in the affirmative, we assume a posture involving a step backward from what we have already achieved. The question is: Do we force entire sub-cultures to accept those enhancements in spite of their cultural and societal norms?
Or…
Should we merely make the technology available if individuals within the sub-culture (or if the entire sub-culture, itself) change their minds?
On a personal note, nearing the age of fifty (in a mere six weeks), if I could maintain a human, bi-pedal form, and maintain my personality – the “Me” inside – I wouldn’t mind having a few ‘upgrades.’ If I had a choice, I might choose to wait until bionanotech matures for a few more years. My twenty-two y/o physical body was rather impressive. (Somebody kidnapped it and left me this old wreck in its place.) If needs must, computer chips and ‘smart’ materials will do nicely for now.
Michael Ben-Nes wrote:
More like, “Yes, because we bred them into existence for that purpose and they would all die horrendous deaths if we didn’t maintain them.”
I think what would have been more useful would be to break down exactly what is meant by enhancement. I think almost everyone who like to live forever young, when that is an option. I think what creeps people out is any kind of cyborgization or deviation from the “conventional” human form.
“Yes, because we bred them into existence for that purpose and they would all die horrendous deaths if we didn’t maintain them.â€
That doesn’t address the real issue at all.
I was surprised by the percentage of people who would not oppose human enhancement. At 85% you’re already at full acceptance. This doesn’t ring true to me. I’d want to see more polling with a broader range of questions that are more specific surrounding the types of enhancements.
“Should certain segments of humanity be allowed to ban all augmented persons and enhancement prosthetics from their countries?”
This goes back to the Federalist v States Rights question or on a more local level the Home Owners Association. Freedom or Equality? Personally I think freedom should trump equality. Throughout US history this was the bias. Today we’re shifting toward equality and less freedom. So more imposed restrictions are the trend.
If a group decides they want to live within a specified context and their group agrees, then they should be allowed to do so. Even if I don’t agree with it. An assumption of not harming other individuals or impeding their freedoms. Also, damaging the larger whole is a concern, but the bias should lean toward the freedom of the individual(s).
Be skeptical of people who Know what is best for other people.
Do you really think that limitations will (or do) apply to those with money and power? Of course it won’t.
“Michael Ben-Nes wrote:
The right is the privilege of the strong. Do we have the right to eat millions of cows ?
Yes, because we can.
Do I subjectively think its ethical? No.
More like, “Yes, because we bred them into existence for that purpose and they would all die horrendous deaths if we didn’t maintain them.†”
THANK YOU, IanC!!
(Though, parenthetically, let’s hope an AGI doesn’t reason that, “since it is maintaining us, it has the right to dispose of us [humans, that is]” Obviously this would not be a particularly “Friendly” thing to do (or way to think), and indeed, to be sure, the analogy is NOT completely like we-are-to-cows…but…)
I think there should be limits on self enhancement just because I fear what will happen when some young kids in a gang decide to give themselves wolverine claws dripping with neurotoxins and decide to go on a killing spree. You can also imagine what some serial killer might decide to do given unlimited freedom to self modify so it is not a good idea.
Of course, everything has its place. Enhancements like that might well be useful for exploring some harsh planet somewhere but if that kid wants to live near me on Earth I would feel safer if he didn’t make himself into a weapon of mass destruction.
JS Berry wrote:
Unfortunately, all this could possibly amount to is the victim disarmament vis a vie “Gun Free Zones”.
My reasoning behind this is somewhat simple: as technology progress, access to newer, more dangerous technologies will be more and more ubiquitous. It is fundamentally impossible to protect the species — let alone the biosphere — simply by regulation.
Better to provide “backups” and “safeguards” rather than “limits.”
MCP2012 Wrote:
I’m glad my perspective bemused you. :) Thankfully, any AGI we build won’t have that perspective. And even then, any AGI that developed it… simply wouldn’t have any use for us that would require our elimination. Hard to explain, but I really think that the “computronium scenario” is an example of our limited comprehension of the universe.
Thanks much, IanC. Yeah, my intuition is that Friendliness can (and hopefully/probably SHALL) evolve, due, at least in part, as I’ve said before, to a concurrent co-evolution of IA and brain-interface tech along with AGI. The next 10-15 yrs well surely tell…Which is to say, I think we’ll get Friendliness partially due to a developing trend toward “coalescence”. This scenario “weirds-out” some folk, ’cause they think it implies Borganization, but it needn’t lead to anything of the sort. (BUT, then again, don’t let the likes of W or Slick Willy—or Dave Rockefeller or Kissinger or Zbig B., for that matter—control or “manage” such development, or we might very well end-up in quasi-Borg crap!)
Related: Have you seen this article on Biotech by Freeman Dyson in the NY Review of Books?
http://www.nybooks.com/articles/20370
I’m not buying those numbers at all. In America alone, something like a fifth of the population are willing to believe that the sun revolves around the earth and close to two fifths believe in The Rapture. To those folks, Human Enhancement is The Devil’s Work!
Getting them to change their minds on that is about as likely as getting you to accept Jesus over a medium rare Porterhouse.
Michael Varian: I have a good deal to say on that topic. “Thankfully” ;), I get to self-promote by way of explanation. And don’t worry — there’s pretty pictures there too. (Most concealed behind links). Sadly, it turns out roughly 2/3rds of Americans believe that evolution is “absolutely not or highly unlikely to be” responsible for the origin of humans. Reduce that to “absolutely not” and you get 1/5th. ‘Course, 18% of those polled also think the sun goes ’round the earth. And of those who think the earth goes ’round the sun, 19% answered that it takes one day to do so. I’m sure you were aware of those numbers — but they bear repeating. Especially to inform you of my level of awareness when I make the following statement:
Such individuals will not be capable of standing in the way of “progress” — it is as simple as asking them this question (and I’ve tried it successfully more than once): do you want only those people whom are out-and-out criminals to be the ones with these augmentations? Only those who would force such changes upon you against your will?
Most religious bio-luddites (the majority of politically potent bio-luddites) disagree with gun control laws. This is simply using the same logic “against them”.
‘Course, I already know how well facts and reason work in winning arguments. :)
The only limits should be the same ones used to create friendly AI. After all, the danger posed by an unfriendly super intelligence is the same whether it is silicon or organic based. There’s no point in creating friendly AI if all its best efforts are undermined by super IA people.
You could argue that if the friendly AI is thousands or millions of times more intelligent than the theoretical limit for human intelligence enhancement, then people can go all the way to that ceiling and the friendly AIs will clean up all their messes. I don’t like this solution.
Then there’s that whole sticky situation about when the enhanced human is no longer human and can be properly thought of as an AI.
Please forgive my bad English.Hello, i think that i saw you visited my web site so i came to “return the favor”.I’m trying to find things to improve my web site!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!
You should be a part of a contest for one of the most useful blogs on the web. I am going to recommend this web site!
Valuable info shared. I am quite pleased to read this post. thanks for giving us nice info. Wonderful walk-through. I appreciate this post.
You could definitely see your skills within the work you write. The arena hopes for more passionate writers like you who are not afraid to say how they believe. Always go after your heart. “No man should marry until he has studied anatomy and dissected at least one woman.” by Honore’ de Balzac.
Interesting website, i read it but i still have a few questions. shoot me an email and we will talk more becasue i may have an interesting idea for you.
A good clear cut answer and a great concept. But how do I post any function on this internet site is yet another question. The Foureyed Poet.
There are definitely quite lots of particulars like that to take into consideration. That may be a fantastic point to bring up. I supply the ideas above as normal inspiration however clearly you’ll find questions like the one you deliver up where a very powerful thing shall be working in sincere very good faith. I don?t know if very best practices have emerged round issues like that, even so I’m certain that your job is clearly recognized as a fair game. Each girls and boys genuinely feel the affect of only a moment’s pleasure, for the rest of their lives.
Your style is very unique compared to other people I have read stuff from. Thank you for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I’ll just bookmark this blog.
The next time I read a blog, Hopefully it doesn’t fail me just as much as this one. After all, Yes, it was my choice to read through, however I actually thought you would probably have something useful to talk about. All I hear is a bunch of moaning about something that you could possibly fix if you weren’t too busy seeking attention.
Hiya, I’m really glad I have located this information and facts. Today bloggers publish only about gossips and world wide web and this is really irritating. A good web web-site with interesting content, that’s what I require. Thanks for keeping this web web page, I will be going to it. Do you do newsletters? Can’t find it.
Its like you learn my thoughts! You seem to know a lot approximately this, like you wrote the ebook in it or something. I think that you could do with some % to drive the message home a little bit, but other than that, this is fantastic blog. A fantastic read. I’ll definitely be back.
You ought to take part in a contest for one of the finest websites on the net. I’m going to highly recommend this web site!
This site certainly has all the info I wanted concerning this subject and didn’t know who to ask.
Thanks for your content. One other thing is when you are selling your property on your own, one of the troubles you need to be alert to upfront is how to deal with house inspection accounts. As a FSBO owner, the key concerning successfully moving your property plus saving money with real estate agent commission rates is knowledge. The more you realize, the smoother your property sales effort will likely be. One area when this is particularly critical is home inspections.
Hello are using WordPress for your blog platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create my own. Do you require any coding expertise to make your own blog? Any help would be really appreciated!
I was very happy to find this internet-site.I wanted to thanks for your time for this excellent read!! I undoubtedly enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you weblog post.more tips i found on !!!
I’m impressed, I must say. Really hardly ever do I encounter a blog that’s each educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you may have hit the nail on the head. Your thought is excellent; the issue is one thing that not sufficient individuals are talking intelligently about. I’m very blissful that I stumbled across this in my search for something regarding this.Useful info!
There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you made sure good factors in options also.some tips here!
You made some decent points there. I regarded on the internet for the issue and located most people will go together with along with your website.more tips i found on!
Oh my goodness! a tremendous article dude. Thanks However I’m experiencing difficulty with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting an identical rss drawback? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkxmore tips i found on!
Spot on with this write-up, I actually suppose this web site wants way more consideration. I’ll probably be again to read much more, thanks for that info.Useful info!
I found your blog site on google and check a number of of your early posts. Proceed to maintain up the excellent operate. I simply additional up your RSS feed to my MSN Information Reader. Seeking forward to studying more from you later on!…more tips i found on!
You need to take part in a contest for the most effective blogs on the web. I will suggest this web site!some tips here!
This website online is known as a walk-by for the entire data you wished about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse right here, and you’ll definitely discover it.
A formidable share, I just given this onto a colleague who was doing a bit analysis on this. And he actually purchased me breakfast because I found it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! However yeah Thnkx for spending the time to debate this, I really feel strongly about it and love reading more on this topic. If potential, as you develop into experience, would you mind updating your blog with more details? It’s extremely helpful for me. Huge thumb up for this blog publish!more tips i found on!
It is best to participate in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will advocate this website!some tips here!
Would anyone who has been a piece on the program from the beginning mind sending me copies on the prior letters? I’m signed up now but unfortunately did not hear of this until now. Many, many many thanks in advance.