Greg Fish over at Weird Things has a post on the Singularity, which is negative about it, and I made a response in the comments. Part of the problem here is the definition of “Singularity” and which one I care about. I don’t care about the word “Singularity” as a synonym for “Progress”. However, as a practical matter, I am concerned that unfriendly AI profoundly threatens the future of the human species. If human-equivalent and human-surpassing AI is possible in principle, it will be developed sooner or later, whether or not transhumanism, life extension, or body modifications are cool at the time. “Transhumanist attitude” is an interesting topic unto itself, but relatively independent of the technical questions of whether AGI is possible, and if so, whether it poses a threat to us, and if so, whether we should do something about it. To me, the answers to all the questions are obviously “yes”.
Transhumanist subcultural identification can be a fun thing, but there’s definitely a limit to how seriously I take it. AI, on the other hand, …